Chiefs Evaluate Veteran Kicker Matt Prater Amid Butker’s Struggles
The Kansas City Chiefs hosted 19-year veteran kicker Matt Prater for a workout on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, as they continue to explore alternatives to struggling kicker Harrison Butker. Butker has converted only 63.2% of his field goals this season, marking a career low. The move comes despite Butker’s 76.9% success rate on his first 13 attempts, which remains below his career average.
On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, the Kansas City Chiefs hosted veteran kicker Matt Prater for a workout, signaling a growing concern over the performance of incumbent kicker Harrison Butker. Butker, who has converted only 63.2% of his field goals this season, is experiencing his lowest success rate in his career, despite a 76.9% conversion rate on his first 13 attempts. The decision to evaluate Prater, a 19-year NFL veteran known for his reliability and long-range accuracy, reflects a strategic move by the Chiefs to explore alternatives amid ongoing struggles in critical kicking situations. The workout occurred at the team’s practice facility in Kansas City, Missouri, and was conducted without public announcement, underscoring the sensitivity of the situation.
Butker, a key contributor to the Chiefs’ recent Super Bowl victories, has long been considered one of the league’s most dependable kickers. His recent decline, however, has raised questions about consistency and performance under pressure, particularly in high-stakes games. The Chiefs’ decision to bring in Prater, who has played for multiple teams including the Denver Broncos and Detroit Lions, suggests a willingness to consider change despite Butker’s past reliability. The team’s front office, coaching staff, and special teams coordinator are all involved in assessing whether a change is warranted, balancing loyalty to a proven performer with the need for peak performance during the playoffs.
What remains unresolved is whether the Chiefs will ultimately replace Butker or continue to support him through the remainder of the season. The team has not yet made a public statement, and no official roster move has been announced. The outcome could hinge on Butker’s ability to improve in upcoming games, as well as the results of any further evaluations involving Prater or other candidates. The situation highlights the high stakes of special teams performance in professional football and the delicate balance between player loyalty and competitive necessity.
The Chiefs’ evaluation of Matt Prater amid Harrison Butker’s struggles could signal a broader trend in the NFL: the increasing scrutiny of specialized roles and the willingness to make bold moves even for long-tenured players. While kickers are often seen as low-risk due to their infrequent involvement, their performance can directly impact game outcomes, especially in tight contests. This situation may prompt other teams to reassess their own special teams units, particularly those with aging or underperforming kickers, potentially leading to a wave of roster adjustments in the coming weeks. A comparable precedent exists in 2018, when the New Orleans Saints replaced veteran kicker Garrett Hartley with rookie kicker Wil Lutz during a critical stretch of the season, ultimately contributing to their playoff run. That case demonstrated how a change in a seemingly minor role can have ripple effects on team morale and performance. In this case, the Chiefs’ decision may affect fan sentiment, especially among loyal supporters who value continuity, while also influencing betting markets and fantasy football dynamics. The next step to watch is whether the Chiefs sign Prater or another veteran, or if they opt to keep Butker with additional support. The outcome could shape how teams approach player evaluation beyond traditional metrics.