GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen Urges Revival of Physical Game Discs Amid GTA 6's Digital Success

GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen has called for a return to physical game discs, arguing that digital-only releases limit consumer rights like resale, trading, and lending. He cited Grand Theft Auto 6's exclusive digital release as a prime example of how such policies harm both players and retailers like GameStop, which profits from used game sales. Cohen accused major publishers of opposing trade-ins to protect new sales revenue.
On November 20, 2026, GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen publicly called for a revival of physical game discs, citing the exclusive digital release of Grand Theft Auto 6 as a pivotal moment in the shift toward digital-only distribution. Cohen argued that digital-only releases deprive consumers of fundamental rights—such as resale, trading, and lending—that are inherent to physical ownership. He emphasized that when players buy a game, they should have full control over it, a principle undermined by digital-only models. GameStop, which relies heavily on trade-in and resale revenue from physical media, stands to lose significantly as digital-only releases eliminate the possibility of used game transactions. Cohen accused major publishers, including those behind GTA 6, of opposing trade-ins to protect new sales revenue, effectively removing competition by limiting consumer choice. This stance aligns with broader industry trends, such as Sony’s announced plan to discontinue physical discs on PlayStation consoles starting January 2028, despite player backlash. The controversy is not isolated; earlier this year, Final Fantasy 7 Revelation faced criticism for requiring a digital download even with a physical disc, highlighting a growing industry pattern of hybrid models that still restrict full ownership.
The issue has also drawn political attention, with U.S. lawmaker Richie Torres introducing the Power To The Players Act, which would empower the Federal Trade Commission to safeguard consumer rights in digital game ownership. The act reflects a growing concern that digital game purchases are effectively rentals, not true sales, since access can be revoked at any time. While Cohen’s call for physical discs is framed as a consumer rights issue, it also serves GameStop’s business interests. The company’s future may depend on whether publishers and platforms reconsider their digital-only strategies or find ways to preserve physical access. What remains unresolved is whether publishers will respond to this pressure, and how regulatory efforts like the Power To The Players Act might evolve. The outcome could reshape not only retail models but also the long-term sustainability of game preservation and secondary markets.
The debate over digital game ownership could reshape consumer rights in the entertainment sector, affecting millions of players, retailers, and collectors. As digital-only releases become standard, the ability to resell, lend, or pass down games diminishes, potentially eroding trust in digital purchases. GameStop’s position reflects a broader tension between corporate revenue models and consumer autonomy—where publishers prioritize new sales over secondary markets, while retailers like GameStop face existential threats. This mirrors earlier conflicts over digital music and e-books, where DRM and licensing restrictions sparked similar debates, though physical media persisted longer in those industries. The rise of digital-only gaming may accelerate the decline of physical retail, impacting not just GameStop but also independent game shops and collectors. However, Microsoft’s recent move to grant digital access via physical discs suggests a potential compromise, possibly signaling a shift toward hybrid models. What may unfold next is a regulatory push to define ownership rights in digital goods, with the Power To The Players Act serving as a possible blueprint. The long-term impact could depend on whether consumers demand more control, or whether platforms continue to prioritize profit over permanence.