Democrats Flip Ohio Supreme Court Majority in 2026 Elections
In the 2026 elections, Democrats won both seats on the Ohio Supreme Court, re-electing incumbent Justice Jennifer L. Brunner and electing Marilyn Zayas to defeat incumbent Dan Hawkins. This marks the first time since 2024 that the court has had a Democratic majority, though it will still maintain a 5-2 Republican majority after Zayas is sworn in. Democrats also won the Ohio governorship, with Amy Acton defeating Vivek Ramaswamy by 7.9 points, ending a 20-year Republican hold on the office.
In the 2026 Ohio elections, Democrats achieved a significant political shift by securing both seats on the Ohio Supreme Court, re-electing Justice Jennifer L. Brunner (D) by a narrow 2.7-point margin and electing Marilyn Zayas (D) to defeat incumbent Dan Hawkins (R). This marks the first Democratic majority on the court since 2024, though the court will still maintain a 5-2 Republican majority after Zayas’s swearing-in. Concurrently, Democrats won the governorship for the first time since 2006, with Amy Acton (D) defeating Republican Vivek Ramaswamy by 7.9 points—a nearly 33-point swing from the 2022 election. Acton, a former physician and director of the Ohio Department of Health, will serve until January 2031 and has the authority to appoint successors to judicial vacancies during her term. Two Republican justices—Pat Fischer and Joseph Deters—are set to reach Ohio’s mandatory retirement age of 70 during her tenure, creating potential openings. Fischer’s term ends in 2028, and if he retires early, Acton could appoint a replacement, possibly shifting the court’s balance. Deters, whose term ends in 2031, may also vacate his seat before then, offering another opportunity for Democratic influence. The political landscape in Ohio has long been dominated by Republicans since 2011, with only Sherrod Brown winning a statewide non-judicial office in that span. Brown’s recent victory in a 2026 special election for the U.S. Senate seat further signals a Democratic resurgence, though his win was narrow.
The 2026 results could signal a broader realignment in Ohio’s political culture, where decades of Republican dominance may be giving way to a more competitive two-party system. With Democrats now controlling the governorship and holding two Supreme Court seats, the state’s judiciary may see shifts in rulings on issues like voting rights, abortion access, and environmental regulation—though the 5-2 Republican majority limits immediate structural change. The ability of Governor Acton to appoint justices during her term could become a pivotal tool in shaping future court decisions, particularly if either Fischer or Deters retires early. This dynamic mirrors the 2018 shift in Wisconsin, where a Democratic governor’s appointments helped alter the court’s ideological balance over time. However, the long-term impact remains uncertain, as the court’s partisan composition is still heavily skewed. What to watch for includes how Acton uses her appointment power, whether the Republican majority will attempt to reform judicial elections, and how voters respond in upcoming elections—especially in 2028 and 2030, when new seats may be contested.