Shrader's 60-yard kicks shake up Colts kicker competition
Spencer Shrader has made a strong case for the Indianapolis Colts' kicking job by hitting two 60-yard field goals in preseason games. He is competing with Blake Grupe, who was previously expected to win the role. Shrader is also returning from an ACL tear.
Spencer Shrader has emerged as a serious challenger in the Indianapolis Colts’ kicking competition, converting two 60-yard field goals during preseason action. That performance directly counters the earlier expectation that Blake Grupe would secure the starting role. Shrader’s bid is all the more notable because he is still working his way back from a torn ACL, adding a layer of resilience to his preseason surge. The Colts now face a genuine decision between Grupe’s consistency and Shrader’s demonstrated long-range power, with the final roster choice likely hinging on practice performance and trust in durability.
This story could affect Colts fans and fantasy football players, who may see a shift in team strategy if Shrader wins the job—his range could allow more aggressive field-position gambles. It may also influence Grupe’s career trajectory, as a preseason setback could send him to another team or practice squad. For the broader NFL, it highlights how undrafted or overlooked kickers can reshape roster battles, reinforcing that preseason leg strength often outweighs prior expectations.