Monken Evaluates Watson Without Reviewing Past Browns Film
Todd Monken said he has not watched any film of Deshaun Watson's previous Browns tenure, instead evaluating him through camp and preseason. Watson missed last season with an Achilles injury and has struggled since joining Cleveland. Monken named Watson the starter over Shedeur Sanders, citing his belief in Watson's ability.
Monken's approach represents a deliberate departure from conventional coaching preparation, as he relies exclusively on live reps rather than historical footage to assess his quarterback. Watson's limited production since 2022—19 games with 19 touchdowns against 12 interceptions—has fueled skepticism among fans who expected more from the blockbuster acquisition.
The decision carries additional weight given Sanders' late-season performance for Cleveland last year, which made him the presumed frontrunner entering camp. Monken's history with Lamar Jackson, who earned MVP honors under his offensive coordination in 2023, lends some credibility to his quarterback development track record, though Watson's injury history remains a significant variable heading into the September 13 opener against Jacksonville.
This quarterback decision could shape public perception of the Browns' leadership and organizational judgment, particularly among a fan base already frustrated by Watson's underperformance. The choice may influence ticket sales, merchandise revenue, and local media coverage throughout the season. If Watson struggles early, Monken's credibility could suffer, potentially affecting team morale and locker room dynamics. Conversely, a revival could restore faith in the franchise's direction and validate a patient, evaluation-based approach to player assessment.