Harbaugh Says Giants Will Add QB Help, Winston Starts Week 3
Giants coach John Harbaugh confirmed the team will add another quarterback after Jaxson Dart's knee injury ended his season. Jameis Winston will start against Tennessee, but Harbaugh said all options, including trades, are on the table. Jake Haener is the only other QB on the roster, on the practice squad.
The injury report confirmed Dart avoided ACL damage but requires surgery for tears to his MCL, PCL, and meniscus, with the meniscus damage posing the biggest complication. A full repair, similar to what sidelined Minnesota's J.J. McCarthy for all of 2024, appears likely. Harbaugh left open the possibility of a postseason return if the Giants make the playoffs.
General manager Joe Schoen did extensive homework on McCarthy before the 2024 draft, and rival executives believe the Vikings' third-string quarterback could be acquired at a value. Winston, meanwhile, hasn't been a full-time starter since 2019 with Tampa Bay, making Sunday's home opener against Tennessee a significant early test for the veteran.
This story could shape the Giants' season and the broader NFC playoff picture. The quarterback decision may influence fan expectations and team morale, while a potential trade for McCarthy could ripple across the league's trade market. Winston's performance may also affect how teams evaluate veteran backup options, and the outcome could impact the careers of both quarterbacks involved.