NextStop’s ‘The Second Best School Shooting’ Finds Dark Humor in Trauma
NextStop Theatre is presenting the U.S. premiere of Alice Stanley Jr.’s dark comedy. The story follows two high school friends processing a recent shooting, social media’s attention economy, and their own trauma. The review credits Alexandra López and Sadie Koopman with powerful and authentic performances.
NextStop Theatre is staging the American debut of Alice Stanley Jr.’s dark comedy after its 2026 Edinburgh Fringe run. The plot follows Parker and Ava, high school friends and recent survivors, during a three-day school closure. Parker characterizes their incident as less than a completed shooting; Ava focuses on another school’s deadlier attack and its larger online response.
Alexandra López plays reserved Parker, while Sadie Koopman plays energetic Ava. Their bond, conflicts, and grief anchor the production. Director Heather Lanza uses a central rectangular stage, bedroom set, lighting, and muffled sound recordings to move between days and flashbacks.
This production may prompt audiences to reflect on how social media can shape responses to tragedy, especially for young people and survivors. Its dark humor could open conversations about grief, comparison, and attention-seeking without minimizing pain. Educators, families, and theatergoers might find it useful for discussing trauma and empathy, though the subject matter may also distress some viewers. It could encourage more nuanced support for those affected by violence.