The Witcher 3: Weighing the Whispering Hillock Spirit Decision
This guide covers the Whispering Hillock quest in The Witcher 3, which begins during the Ladies of the Wood storyline after Geralt is asked to aid Downwarren. It outlines the available choices involving the trapped tree spirit and explains how each outcome can affect Downwarren, the children, and Anna.
The Whispering Hillock unfolds within The Witcher 3's Ladies of the Wood storyline. After Geralt agrees to assist Downwarren, its ealdorman points him toward the Ancient Oak, where a voice draws him to a spirit imprisoned under the tree.
Reaching it involves fighting wolves, a werewolf at a cave mouth, and flooded tunnels. If Geralt aids the spirit, he gathers a raven feather, the spirit's bones, and a black horse. The feather may already be held from Johnny's harpy-nest task.
This quest's morally tangled outcomes could affect players who seek guidance, as they may weigh consequences for Downwarren, the children, and Anna before acting. Guide readers and fan communities may use such discussions to compare interpretations, deepening engagement with The Witcher 3's choice-driven storytelling. The decision's emotional weight may also encourage reflection on how games present ambiguous ethical dilemmas, though its real-world influence is likely limited to entertainment and fandom.