New York City Sues Manhattan Law Firm Over Alleged Personal Injury Fraud
New York City has sued Manhattan law firm Asher & Associates and its principals, alleging a personal injury fraud scheme that sought tens of millions of dollars from the city. Officials said the firm's claims sometimes conflicted with medical records, including a 2022 bicycle crash case where injuries were allegedly from a fight. The lawsuit was filed in Manhattan Federal Court.
New York City officials announced the suit against Asher & Associates, P.S., along with Ryan Asher and Roberta Asher. The complaint was filed in Manhattan Federal Court. Corporation Counsel Steven Banks and Transportation Commissioner Mike Flynn publicized the action.
The city claims the firm pursued tens of millions of dollars over incidents that differed from court descriptions. In a 2022 Brooklyn bicycle case on Utica Avenue, the firm reportedly sought $3 million for roadway-caused injuries, but city officials say medical records linked those injuries to a fight. Reporting also noted clients gave emergency room staff accounts that later changed in damages claims.
If proven, the allegations could affect public trust in injury litigation and city finances. Taxpayers may bear costs when questionable claims are paid, while genuine accident victims could face greater scrutiny. Law firms and insurers may review screening practices. Courts could see more challenges to medical evidence and client accounts. The case may also shape how municipalities pursue fraud claims against attorneys.