Panel weighs McCarthy's Giants role, Ravens' division standing
A studio panel debated whether J.J. McCarthy should become the Giants' starting quarterback. The group also discussed whether Baltimore remains the best team in the AFC North.
The segment featured Devin McCourty, Jason Garrett and Jac Collinsworth weighing whether J.J. McCarthy should take over as the Giants’ starting quarterback. A related clip highlighted McCarthy’s showing for the Giants in a loss to the Saints, while another asked if the Giants should turn to him as starter.
The same panel also considered Baltimore’s standing in the AFC North, with a separate speed-round clip posing which team is best in that division. The discussion aired as part of an October 19, 2026, video page that also linked clips on other NFL quarterback situations and Week 6 results.
This debate could shape how Giants fans, players, and coaches view the team’s quarterback plans, especially if McCarthy’s showing leads to more starts. Baltimore’s AFC North standing may affect rival fanbases and playoff expectations. For media, such panel segments may drive engagement and speculation, though actual decisions remain with coaches and front offices.