Michigan Reportedly Turns to Carr at Quarterback Against Indiana
Michigan is expected to start freshman Tommy Carr at quarterback against Indiana instead of Bryce Underwood, according to a report. Carr relieved Underwood in the previous game against Penn State and helped Michigan rally for a 21-18 win. Underwood, a former top recruit, has struggled with consistency and turnovers.
CBS Sports' Matt Zenitz reported Tuesday that Michigan is likely to give freshman Tommy Carr the start Saturday versus Indiana, replacing Bryce Underwood. Carr came off the bench at Penn State and helped the Wolverines rally for a 21-18 win.
Underwood entered as the top overall prospect in the 2025 class, according to 247Sports' composite. His Michigan tenure has included uneven play and turnovers: 11 touchdowns and nine interceptions as a freshman, then 924 yards, five scores and six picks at a 58.1% completion rate this season. Michigan sits at 4-2 with Indiana, UCLA, Oregon and Ohio State ahead.
The switch could affect Michigan players, students and fans by shifting expectations for the team’s playoff push and changing how a high-profile young quarterback is discussed publicly. It may also influence how recruits and their families view development and patience at major programs, while giving broadcasters and social media a new storyline. Because college athletes are closely watched, coverage of Carr and Underwood could shape public conversations about pressure, opportunity and fair treatment, though on-field results will likely determine the lasting impact.