Supreme Court Justice Nominee Fails to Recall Key Constitutional Amendment

Texas Supreme Court Justice James P. Sullivan could not recall the content of the Twenty-Second Amendment during a Senate confirmation hearing, even after being prompted by Senator Chris Coons. When asked whether Donald Trump could run for president again in 2028, Sullivan declined to answer, citing judicial ethics, despite the amendment’s clear limit on presidential terms. The exchange drew criticism for highlighting a nominee’s apparent lack of constitutional knowledge.
Texas Supreme Court Justice James P. Sullivan, nominated by President Donald Trump to serve on a federal district court, faced intense scrutiny during a November 18, 2026, Senate Judiciary Committee hearing when he failed to recall the content of the Twenty-Second Amendment. When questioned by Senator Chris Coons of Delaware, Sullivan initially could not state the amendment’s provisions, despite being prompted with the opening phrase “No person shall be elected.” After Coons clarified it, Sullivan acknowledged the amendment limits a person to two elected terms as president. He confirmed that Trump had been elected in 2016 and 2024, but refused to answer whether Trump could run again in 2028, citing Canon 5 of the American Bar Association’s Code of Judicial Conduct, which prohibits judicial nominees from commenting on political matters. This refusal drew sharp criticism, especially given Trump’s repeated public statements—first in March 2025 and again in an April 2026 Time magazine interview—about exploring constitutional “loopholes” to serve a third term. The incident underscores growing concerns about judicial nominees’ foundational knowledge of constitutional law, particularly when the issue involves a sitting president’s eligibility. The broader context includes a pattern of political figures challenging constitutional norms, and the nomination process now faces heightened scrutiny over whether nominees possess not just legal expertise but a clear grasp of the nation’s foundational texts. What remains unresolved is whether the Senate will proceed with the nomination despite the perceived constitutional illiteracy, and how this episode may influence future judicial vetting standards.
The incident could erode public confidence in the judiciary’s perceived neutrality, especially when a nominee appears to evade a straightforward constitutional question. While judicial ethics require restraint on political matters, the refusal to affirm a clear constitutional provision—especially one directly relevant to a sitting president—may be seen as a failure of basic civic literacy. This moment may amplify calls for more rigorous vetting of nominees, particularly on foundational constitutional knowledge, potentially influencing future confirmation processes. A comparable precedent is the 2005 nomination of Harriet Miers, whose lack of judicial experience sparked controversy, though her case centered on legal philosophy rather than constitutional literacy. Here, the stakes are higher due to the direct confrontation with a president’s constitutional eligibility. The broader impact may extend to public discourse on the rule of law, with critics arguing that judicial nominees should be expected to understand core constitutional limits. What to watch for next is whether the Senate Judiciary Committee will demand a written clarification from Sullivan or whether the nomination will be delayed or withdrawn. The episode may also prompt renewed debate over whether nominees should be required to demonstrate constitutional literacy as part of the confirmation process.